Skip to main content
SeaOtter/Legal

Published adjudication logic

A machine decides. A person can be asked.

Work is accepted against checks that were written into the contract before anyone started. Here is what those checks are, what each outcome does to the money, and how to have a person look at any of it — free, and without the money moving while they do.

Version
beta-3-20260803
Effective
August 3, 2026

On this page

  1. What happens to delivered work
  2. The three outcomes
  3. How the checking is done
  4. If you disagree
  • 8 of 11 acceptance methods in use
  • 34 named checks

What happens to delivered work

The sealed contractwritten before anyone startedThe delivered workexactly what was handed overThe agreed checks runno new rule is invented hereAcceptedMoneymovesRefused, with evidenceNothingis chargedCould not be runNothingmovesAsk a person — free, either sideThe money stays whereit is while they look.

The contract's checks run against what was handed over. Three outcomes are possible, and only one of them moves money.

The three outcomes

Every acceptance ends in exactly one of these. Nothing else is reachable.

Accept

Reached when
Every check that was required by the sealed contract passed.
Money
The agreed amount moves to the person who did the work.
Who can ask for a person
The buyer who paid

Reject with evidence

Reached when
At least one required check failed, and the failure was observed rather than inferred.
Money
Nothing is charged. The held amount returns to the buyer once the work has run out of attempts.
Who can ask for a person
The person who did the work

Inconclusive

Reached when
A required check could not be run at all — our instrument failed, not the work.
Money
Nothing moves and nothing is held against anyone. The check is run again, and a person is asked to look if it fails again.
Who can ask for a person
—

How the checking is done

Different shapes of work are judged in different ways, and the contract says which before you agree to it. Each method below lists the checks that belong to it, in the words the contract uses.

Deterministic probeIn use24
  • Authorities bind

    We check every citation in the document against the document's own list of authorities, so nothing is cited that was never listed. Whether the authority actually supports the point is the practitioner's call, and they sign for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Authority currency

    We check that every law or rule cited says when it was current, and that none of them is older than the date you asked for

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Axe scan delta

    We check the page for accessibility problems ourselves, as it was and as it is now, and show you what changed — these are automated findings, not a legal opinion

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look at the page as it was and as it is now · Concludes: On delivery

  • Citations resolve

    We open every address the report cites, one by one, and check each one still answers — and where the report puts words in quotation marks, we read them back off the source to see they are really there

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Consent dismissable

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Console clean

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Deadline within days

    We measure what was handed over against what was agreed

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Deliverable format is

    We measure what was handed over against what was agreed

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Design spec conformance

    We open the delivered images ourselves, shrink them to every size you said you would use them at, and measure what still reads at each one — this checks the drawing survives the sizes, never whether you like it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Document completeness

    We check the delivered document covers every section of the outline you gave — measured against your outline, never a template we decided on

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Element absent

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Element exists

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Filing receipt present

    We check the delivery carries the filing confirmation from the office you named. We never tell you it will be granted — nobody can

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • No site challenge

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Outline has

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Provenance screen

    We measure what was handed over against what was agreed

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Quantity at least

    We measure what was handed over against what was agreed

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Report structure

    We read the delivered report and count what you asked for: the sections you named, in the order you named them, and a body inside the length you agreed

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Requests clean

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Task completes

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Text absent

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Text present

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Url reaches

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

  • Viewport pass

    We open the page ourselves and look — no one's word is taken for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we open your page the way any visitor would · Concludes: On delivery

Sealed sandbox rerunIn use1
  • Sandbox run passes

    We run the delivered work ourselves in a locked-down box and watch how it finishes

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

Driven sessionIn use1
  • Interactive session passes

    We click, type, and play through it ourselves, the way you would

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

Recompute reconciliationIn use1
  • Recompute reconciliation

    We work out every total on the report ourselves, from your own source files, and they have to match — the delivered number is never taken at its word

    What we need from you: You give us the source files the numbers come from, pinned at the moment we agree, so we can work them out ourselves · Concludes: On delivery

Per item batchIn use1
  • Catalog rows reconcile

    We check every item on its own against your own master file — each one must be there, complete, and matching, so a failing item never hides inside the batch

    What we need from you: You give us the source files the numbers come from, pinned at the moment we agree, so we can work them out ourselves · Concludes: On delivery

Reference pack conformanceIn use2
  • Content compliance

    The delivered work is screened for age rating and copyright risk, with the exact moments that triggered each call

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Matches reference

    We compare it against the reference material you gave us

    What we need from you: We need nothing beyond the reference material you already showed us · Concludes: On delivery

Experiment reproductionIn use3
  • Experiment reproduces

    We run the delivered work ourselves, twice, and work out every number the report gives — each one has to come out the same as ours, inside the tolerance you agreed. What the author says their own result was is never the evidence for it

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

  • Gpu serve probe

    We load the model on the agreed setup and measure it ourselves on held-back examples

    What we need from you: You give us the held-back examples to measure against, sealed at the moment we agree · Concludes: On delivery

  • Strategy backtest replay

    We rerun the strategy ourselves over the pinned history and measure it again on a stretch it was never shown

    What we need from you: You give us the historical data the claim rests on, pinned at the moment we agree, so we can measure it ourselves · Concludes: On delivery

Human review tierIn use1
  • Semantic pass

    A reading is made of whether it says what was agreed, and a person stands behind that reading

    What we need from you: We need nothing of yours to check this — we look only at what was handed over · Concludes: On delivery

Temporal windowNamed, not yet in use
Taste roundsNamed, not yet in use
Licensed signoffNamed, not yet in use

These shapes exist in the contract vocabulary, but nothing here judges them yet. A contract that asks for one is refused rather than quietly judged some other way.

If you disagree

No person decides whether the checks passed. That is exactly why you can ask for one.

  • You have 14 days from the decision to ask.
  • A person looks at every case within one business day, and both sides hear the answer.
  • Asking is free for both sides and stays free.
  • If you disagree with what the person decides, you may appeal that once, within 7 days.

You bought the work

If the checks passed and you do not think the work is what you paid for, say so on the receipt. The charge is contested from that moment.

You did the work

If the checks refused your delivery, appeal it from your copy of the same receipt. It is the same document, with the same evidence, on both sides.

The money while you waitWhile a dispute is open, the job's money is frozen where it sits: an undrawn escrow hold stays held, and a drawn payout is not cashable until the case resolves.

Dispute resolution terms beta-3-20260803 — a plain-language template pending review by counsel.